Council considers budget amendments, raises spending for Chamber of Commerce

Oak Ridge City Council Budget Meeting

The Oak Ridge City Council considers a series of potential budget amendments during a special meeting Thursday.

They were scheduled to consider more than a dozen budget amendments Thursday, but Oak Ridge City Council members approved only one that could immediately affect spending. It was a recommendation to spend another $50,000 on the Oak Ridge Chamber of Commerce contract.

The proposal will be considered by the City Council during the second and final budget reading on May 28. The new fiscal year starts July 1.

During a special four-hour meeting Thursday, Council rejected other proposals to increase spending on capital maintenance by $250,000 and cut spending on travel. Members asked for further study on a recommendation to consider relocating Fire Station No. 2 in east Oak Ridge to Melton Lake Drive. [Read more...]

Council members clash over Baughn’s budget-cutting proposals

Trina Baughn

Trina Baughn

Charlie Hensley

Charlie Hensley

Several Oak Ridge City Council members clashed on Monday as they debated a few last-minute proposals to reduce city spending in some areas and increase it in others.

Most of the debate centered on proposals submitted by Oak Ridge City Council member Trina Baughn. She asked the City Council to consider nine budget-cutting proposals and consider selling the Centennial Golf Course and the property used by the Oak Ridge Chamber of Commerce, among other things.

Baughn said she represents the citizens of Oak Ridge and is trying to find the highest and best use of city-owned property. She has previously said she would like to lower the property tax rate and has advocated for a more limited government. [Read more...]

Guest column: It’s not the property tax rate

There is a persistent plaint that workers at Y-12 National Security Complex and Oak Ridge National Laboratory don’t live in Oak Ridge because the property tax rate is so high. Farragut is pointed to as having no city tax at all and therefore highly attractive. Farragut, no less than Oak Ridge, is indeed an attractive area in which to live. It is not because of the property tax rate.

Let’s look at a few of the numbers related to the Oak Ridge city tax rate of $2.39. That rate is applied per $100 of value on 25 percent of the assessed value of residential property. In other words, if one’s home has been appraised at $150,000, the epitome of an “affordable” home, the city property tax is $2.39 per hundred dollars on $37,500, or $896.25. That means that this homeowner is paying just at $75 per month for city services.

Among the services covered by this $75 are police, fire fighters, parks and recreational services, library, street lights, sidewalks, code oversight, street maintenance, and the city’s contribution to the schools. That is $75 per household, not for each person. [Read more...]

Council approves Protomet tax break, ends recycling rewards program

A five-year, 100 percent tax break for parts manufacturer Protomet was approved in a 4-1 vote by the Oak Ridge City Council on Monday.

The tax break could be used to help Protomet more than double the size of its 15,000-square-foot plant in the Bethel Valley Industrial Park, consolidate operations with a Blount County facility, and add 20-30 workers.

Also Monday, the City Council agreed in a voice vote, with no objections, to end the RecycleBank Reward Program and determine later what to do with the savings of $0.84 per household per month. The savings are expected to add up to about $124,000 each year. [Read more...]

Protomet could use tax break to double plant size, add workers

A tax break recommended by an Oak Ridge board on Monday could help a parts manufacturer more than double the size of its plant and add 20-30 workers, an executive said.

The Oak Ridge Industrial Development Board endorsed the five-year, 100 percent property tax break for Protomet—which makes marine, automotive, and homeland security equipment—in a special meeting Monday.

But Oak Ridge City Council member Anne Garcia Garland suggested there could be some opposition later. She said residents want to know why Protomet, which has become successful with the help of one tax abatement, should receive another. [Read more...]

Council approves $18 million in borrowing for sewer system repairs

Trina Baughn

Trina Baughn

After more than an hour of discussion, the Oak Ridge City Council on Monday approved the borrowing of $18 million in low-interest state loans to help pay for a $23 million project to fix the municipal sewer system.

Council voted 6-1 to borrow the money at a 1.23 percent interest rate through the State Revolving Fund program, which is administered by the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation.

The work is being done to comply with a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency order that requires Oak Ridge to repair all sewer system overflows by Sept. 28, 2015.

[Read more...]

Report: Oak Ridge officials discuss wastewater issues with EPA in Atlanta

Editor’s note: The Oak Ridge City Council recently established an ad hoc subcommittee to focus on issues related to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency administrative order on inflow and infiltration of the city’s wastewater system. Councilman Chuck Hope, who is chairman of the subcommittee, provided the following report on its recent meeting with the EPA in Atlanta.

The subcommittee of City Council that was formed to address our EPA Administrative Order concerns, went to Atlanta, Ga., on Tuesday, Feb. 5, 2013, to meet with staff from the Southeast Regional (Region 4) EPA office.

The meeting was attended by four EPA staff members: Denisse Diaz, clean water enforcement branch chief; Maurice Horsey, municipal and industrial enforcement section chief; Michele Whetherington, assistant regional counsel; and Dennis Sayre, our assigned contact in municipal and industrial enforcement.

[Read more...]

Two City Council members appointed to National League of Cities committees

Oak Ridge City Council

The Oak Ridge City Council is pictured above. Anne Garcia Garland is pictured at left and David Mosby is at right.

Two Oak Ridge City Council members have been appointed to key National League of Cities committees, a city press release said.

National League of Cities President Marie Lopez Rogers has announced the appointment of Oak Ridge City Council member Anne Garcia Garland to the National League of Cities 2013 Community and Economic Development Steering Committee, and the re-appointment of Council member David Mosby to the Energy, Environment, and Natural Resources Steering Committee, the press release said.

[Read more...]

Guest column: Report on National League of Cities conference trip

The National League of Cities Congress of Cities and Expo differs from the other annual conference held in Washington. The Legislative Conference is focused on interfacing with federal elected officials and agencies and considering the national agenda. This year’s conference in Boston is the one that focuses on bringing together local officials from all over the country to share ideas and solutions to local issues.

This year’s foci were on promoting strong local economies, building sustainable communities, and strengthening neighborhoods and families. There were workshops on how businesses, individuals, groups, governments, and communities are being affected by the recession. There were presentations and roundtable discussions on common issues and ongoing solutions.

[Read more...]

Letter: Garcia Garland endorses Smith, Baughn

To the Editor:

People keep asking me, so I decided to simply publish my recommendations for City Council.

First, please consider returning Ellen Smith to Council. Ms. Smith has the qualities of openness, responsiveness, and inviolate ethics that everyone hopes for in elected representatives. In addition, she does her homework better than any of the rest of us. She keeps abreast of what is going on in town and among the many entities which influence the town’’s well-being. She avoids hurting anyone’s feelings if possible but will stand firm for what she believes is in the citizen’s’ best interest. Her research always helps expand my understanding of issues.

Next, I would like the chance to work with Trina Baughn. This lady also brings diligence and integrity to the table even while challenging “”the way we’’ve always done it”” thinking. She asks for and pursues facts upon which to make decisions. When we differ in economic or social philosophy, I have always found her willing to listen and even eager to find workable common ground. She inspires me to work harder to be well-informed. In addition, Trina brings a maturity of thoughtfulness belied by her youth and an understanding of the interests of young adults and families here.

All the candidates have their strengths and weaknesses, and I will do my best to work well with whomever you choose. Thank you for considering my view.

Anne Garcia Garland

Oak Ridge City Council member

Guest column: Council member outlines recent economic changes

(Editor’s note: The following is a speech on the city’s vision and economic development given by Oak Ridge City Council member Anne Garcia Garland to the local branch of the American Association of University Women on Monday.)

I would like to start with a couple questions of my own.

How many of you have lived in Oak Ridge for more than 20 years? How many of you have been members of American Association of University Women here for 20 or more years?

In those two decades, how many of you have noticed changes in the city that you aren’t happy with? How about changes that you are happy with? You are allowed to answer yes to both.

Coincidentally to this talk, yesterday our pastor at United Church preached a sermon on change. Change is neither good nor bad. It’s just change, and it is inevitable. And even change that looks bad can turn out to be for the long-term good when we respond to it in productive ways.

So let’s take an east-to-west look at some of the recent changes in the city’s economic picture. Elza Park is paved and the walk and bike trail now extends from Elza past the Marina basin over the hill, under Edgemoor, around Haw Ridge, and on to connect with Pellissippi at the Solway Bridge. We lost some picnic tables and gained some waterfront access on foot.

There are new automotive services at the first intersection of the Turnpike. Tractor Supply is thriving in the former east-end Food City building. R&R Properties continue their rejuvenation of office and commercial properties, and new reconstruction now at Fairbanks Plaza. Dollar General built a nice stand-alone building at Florida, and Enterprise car rental has snapped up the vacated Sonic location. Eddie Hair has expanded impressively, and there is a new Ace Hardware across the street as well as a new car sales business.

Roane State has broken ground on a multimillion-dollar expansion, and the commercial spaces in front of National Fitness are filling in.

There are new restaurants and a new bank in the Jackson Square area. The state has agreed to help fund the upgrading of the interior parking area for the square. Jackson Plaza, our one and only skyscraper, has enthusiastic new businesses, which continue to expand their employee numbers.

There are some gaps to be filled, but from Florida to the new AT&T building, there are no glaringly empty commercial sites.

Now we move on to Illinois, where things are looking very positive for a Kroger Marketplace. Provided no disasters befall the site, this Kroger installation is a bellwether (in a most intelligent form) of commerce to come. There are many national retailers who gladly follow a Kroger expansion. Kroger will be presenting designs that accommodate whatever decision this church (Unitarian Universalist Church) decides they would prefer to do. Their presence will not only bring new retail within their center, it will very likely encourage new commerce in historic Grove Center. There are even tenants already being considered for the current Kroger location.

Up Illinois, new restaurants are being built along the edge of Woodland. Weigel’s is proposing to build a new location next door to TnBank. I think we will see the Illinois corridor fill up and rejuvenate over the next two or three years in additional significant ways. There are solid citizen stores already in place and interest in more. Holiday Inn Express has joined the hotels in Oak Ridge in anticipation of a coming need.

So, let me get to some of the coming need.

There is already a list of some 400 businesses asking to qualify to be suppliers to the Department of Energy’s Uranium Processing Facility. This will be a multibillion-dollar construction project on the federal reservation. There will be many contractors joining our local ones to serve the construction needs of this Last Great Build. That, by the way, is a phrase which I attribute to John Eschenberg, the fella DOE has put in charge of the build. John took the time to come to council and describe the project. And while he was there, he urged us to jump into this build with both feet.

The Holiday Inn may have decided to build here partly because of the UPF build. I believe they are also here because they see the advent of increased commerce and travel with the opening of the final four-laning of Highway 95 between I-75 and I-40.

Let me go back a minute to the elephant in the room. For a number of years, the increasingly abandoned mall has been just that. With the construction of the Kroger marketplace, the commercial center of town CHANGES. Some of you probably remember when Jackson Square was town center. The mall and the civic center shifted “town center” to the Turnpike and Tulane. After this build, the commercial center once again shifts, this time to the western side of the civic center. Once Kroger Marketplace is open, what was The Mall will become virtually invisible. This makes me sad for JCPenney and Belk, who have been faithful to us. But it means we will no longer be waiting for Mr. Arnsdorff and Mr. Thrash, et al., to do anything. Oak Ridge is moving forward.

So far, I have been talking about commerce. Let me turn to tourism and then industry. With the opening of our four-lane connector between I-75 and I-40, we become an alternate route for folks who have already seen Knoxville. National Park or no, and I certainly hope this park will become a reality, if we partner with Clinton, Andersonville, Norris, Briceville, Oliver Springs, Kingston, and Harriman, we have enough historic places and natural treasures to become an equally attractive complement to Gatlinburg and Townsend. Oak Ridge is halfway between a LOT of places. Our entire area could be a destination as well as a stopover.

We also have within this city, commercial, office, and industrial sites ready for renovation, construction, or repurposing. DOE has been the industrial cornerstone for Oak Ridge for many years. We have some other industry for which we are grateful, and we are looking for more. We also have neighbor towns bringing industry to the area, from which we all benefit. Within probably a decade, we may well also be the center of carbon fiber industry for the nation.

As for housing, we are so fortunate to have a wealth of affordable houses, townhouses, apartments, condos, and more. We do have a few serious challenges in some of the original housing areas, but we have heard too much of the city myth that “the old housing is a problem.” Most of the old housing is no problem at all.  It includes amazing renovations and personalizations as well as modest starter homes. There is a tremendous wealth of mid-century modern homes in Oak Ridge as well as quite a few well-built ’70s and ’80s homes in neighborhoods that are now established and beautiful. There are elegant new homes in Wolf Creek and Grove Park, and there are new neighborhoods with additional modern homes in the west end. New housing starts have been near a standstill since the recession hit, but it has more to do with available lending than with any lack of plats or infrastructure. Still, Oak Ridge did not have a bubble so it hasn’t had a bust. Houses have maintained their values. As lending returns to the residential market, I think new home construction will renew with vigor.

So, about all this change. Most of us feel better about change if we believe we can influence its direction and have choices in encountering it. That’s when we get to my campaign speeches of three years ago. We need to re-engage. We need to not wait for city hall to tell us where we are going but get ourselves together and tell city hall where we prefer to go.

Council member discusses economic development Monday

Oak Ridge City Council member Anne Garcia Garland will discuss local economic development during a Monday evening meeting of the local branch of the American Association of University Women.

Garcia Garland’s talk is titled “Vision and Economic Development: What is Going on in the City.” It starts at 7 p.m. in the Social Room of the Unitarian Universalist Church.

[Read more...]