• About
    • About Us
    • What We Cover
  • Advertise
    • Advertise
    • Our Advertisers
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Send News
  • Subscribe

Oak Ridge Today

  • Home
  • Sign in
  • News
    • Business
    • Community
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Police and Fire
    • U.S. Department of Energy
    • Weather
  • Sports
    • High School
    • Middle School
    • Recreation
    • Rowing
    • Youth
  • Entertainment
    • Arts
    • Dancing
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Television
    • Theater
  • Premium Content
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds




Council wants to roughly triple proposed water rate at ORNL, Y-12

Posted at 5:39 pm September 13, 2016
By John Huotari 3 Comments

Oak-Ridge-Water-Treatment-Plant-2009-1

The Oak Ridge Water Treatment Plant is pictured on Pine Ridge above the Y-12 National Security Complex. (Photo by City of Oak Ridge)

 

Note: This story was updated at 6:50 p.m.

Some Oak Ridge City Council members have questioned whether the federal government is paying enough for municipal water at Oak Ridge National Laboratory and Y-12 National Security Complex, and on Monday, four of them proposed roughly tripling a potential new high-volume water rate at the two federal sites in 2017.

The new water rate would apply to water consumption over 20 million gallons per month, which would limit it to ORNL and Y-12. The two sites use a total of more than 100 million gallons of water per month.

The new rate is expected to go into effect in April 2017 only if Oak Ridge and the U.S. Department of Energy aren’t able to agree on a contract for water at ORNL and Y-12 by the end of March. Those two federal sites now pay a flat annual rate but could default to what is known as a retail rate if the contract lapses.

The city staff had proposed a new default rate of $1.08 per thousand gallons for consumption over 20 million gallons starting January 1, 2017. The following year, in 2018, the staff had proposed a $1.35 rate.

But four City Council members—Rick Chinn, Charlie Hensley, Trina Baughn, and Chuck Hope—voted to raise the $1.08 rate in 2017 to $3 per 1,000 gallons. Oak Ridge Mayor Warren Gooch, Mayor Pro Tem Ellen Smith, and Council member Kelly Callison voted against the increase.

Advertisement

Chinn said there is a huge discrepancy between the DOE rate at ORNL and Y-12, and the average household rate.

For example, the proposed new water rates that were approved by Council in the first of two readings on Monday would have a residential customer who exceeds the minimum 2,000 gallon consumption pay $7.05 per 1,000 gallons for consumption between 3,000 and 10,000 gallons.

Meanwhile, DOE is paying about $1.68 per 1,000 gallons of water, city officials said in March. On Monday, Oak Ridge Finance Director Janice McGinnis said the DOE rate was budgeted at $1.84 in 2017 and $2.10 in 2018.

“They’re getting a really good deal,” Chinn said of the DOE rate.

Chinn made the motion to raise the proposed new rate on consumption over 20 million gallons from $1.08 per 1,000 gallons to $3, twice the current production cost. That’s the rate that could go into effect in 2017 if the city and DOE can’t agree on a new water contract at ORNL and Y-12.

Hensley, who has been critical of the payments in lieu of taxes that DOE pays on its large tracts of land in Oak Ridge, provided a second to Chinn’s motion.

“I’d like to get their attention,” Hensley said.

Hensley has said that Oak Ridge residents are subsidizing the federal operation, and the department is taking advantage of the city. He said he doesn’t think the relationship could get any worse.

oak-ridge-city-council-rick-chinn-sept-14-2015

Rick Chinn (File photo by John Huotari/Oak Ridge Today)

Baughn, who has also raised concerns about the DOE rate compared to the average household rate, supported Chinn’s proposal to roughly triple the proposed high-volume rate for ORNL and Y-12.

“No matter how you slice it, put yourself in the average ratepayer’s shoes, and this stinks,” she said Monday. “DOE (at ORNL and Y-12) is paying two (to) three times less for the water…I’m tired of paying so much for water and sewer. I’m tired of seeing it doubled.”

Hope also supported the proposal. He has previously suggested that DOE ought to at least pay whatever it costs the city to make water. He did so again Monday.

In response to questions from Hope, Oak Ridge Finance Director Janice McGinnis said it costs about $1.50 to produce 1,000 gallons of water, although the cost can vary. She said the rate that the city charges DOE is more than or equal to the production cost.

The original DOE rate considered by City Council on Monday, the one that had been proposed by city staff and then increased by Council, was calculated by a consultant to cover 50 percent of the city’s water production costs, McGinnis said.

DOE officials and city staff members have suggested that Council members might not want to directly compare the retail water rates inside the city with the water rates at ORNL and Y-12. That’s because, unlike the city’s retail water customers, ORNL and Y-12 do not pay for distribution costs inside the city.

Those costs include the expenses associated with maintaining and operating a few hundred miles of water lines and pumping systems. Those distribution costs are estimated to be more than half of the total water costs in the city.

ORNL and Y-12 get their water from the Oak Ridge water plant on Pine Ridge above Y-12 and they pay half of the production costs, but the sites have their own separate distribution systems and costs, officials said. When a water line needs repair at ORNL or Y-12, Oak Ridge City Manager Mark Watson told Council members Monday, workers at those sites fix it, and not the City of Oak Ridge.

Advertisement

Council members who voted against the Monday night proposal to about triple the high-volume rate for ORNL and Y-12 in 2017 said they weren’t necessarily opposed to a number higher than $1.08, but they want more information.

Smith, the mayor pro tem, proposed deferring the discussion, saying if municipal officials raise the rate significantly higher than $1.08, DOE might not take the city seriously and the relationship could become more difficult. She said she wanted to be able to discuss the proposal with legal counsel and the city’s rate consultant.

“We’ve been advised in the past that DOE won’t take us seriously if we start suggesting we’re going to charge them a whole lot more than it costs us to provide water to them,” Smith said.

She said the new retail rate was calculated to ensure that, if a contract isn’t reached by early next year, the city could still charge ORNL and Y-12 for water. The new rate is calculated to ensure that the city can get the kind of money it needs to run the part of the water system used to serve DOE, Smith said.

“The fact that these numbers look low is only related to the fact that they use a huge amount of water and they maintain their own distribution system instead of ours,” Smith said. “They’ll still be our biggest customer.”

Gooch, the city’s mayor, said the rate could possibly be raised, but he wants more information on the true rate structure.

City Council Chuck Hope, Warren Gooch, and Ellen Smith on Sept. 14, 2015

Pictured above at the Oak Ridge City Council meeting on Monday, Sept. 14, 2015, are Council members Chuck Hope, left, Mayor Warren Gooch, and Mayor Pro Tem Ellen Smith. (File photo by John Huotari/Oak Ridge Today)

 

After they amended the rate increases to roughly triple the high-volume water rate for ORNL and Y-12 in 2017, Council members voted 5-2 for the water and wastewater rate increases. Baughn and Callison, who did not support the larger rate increase for ORNL and Y-12 in 2017, voted “no.”

During a discussion with McGinnis, Callison had confirmed that there was an economic basis for the staff’s proposed 20-million-gallon rate for DOE, the rate that had been proposed at $1.08 per 1,000 gallons but was increased by Council members to $3 in 2017.

Monday’s vote on the water and wastewater rate increases, which also apply to homes and businesses in Oak Ridge, was the first of two votes, or readings. The second vote is expected in October.

The proposed increases would raise water and sewer rates by 6 percent starting January 1, 2017. The next year, effective January 1, 2018, a 4 percent increase has been proposed for water rates and a 6 percent increase has been proposed for sewer rates.

A home that uses the minimum amount would pay an extra $2.26 per month for water and sewer starting in 2017 and an additional $2.17 per month in 2018.

A home that uses 5,000 gallons per month would pay $5.33 more per month for both water and sewer in 2017 and another $4.87 in 2018.

Advertisement

McGinnis has said the rate increases are required to continue to operate and maintain the systems, perform necessary capital improvements, and meet contractual and debt service obligations.

The water rates being discussed at ORNL and Y-12 are different from the rates paid at other DOE sites, such as the Oak Ridge Office and East Tennessee Technology Park. Those sites pay what is known as a retail rate. That’s a rate like residents pay, and the rate can vary depending upon a few factors, including monthly consumption.

The public discussion over the DOE rates started in March, when City Council approved a one-year, $2.1 million contract extension for water supplied to ORNL and Y-12. The fixed-rate extension was approved in a 4-2 vote, and it is for up to 1,619,000,000 gallons of water at ORNL and Y-12 through March 31, 2017.

The one-year water contract extension was expected to give the city time to have a qualified third-party engineering firm study the city’s aging water plant on Pine Ridge, consider what is needed, and develop options that could help Oak Ridge decide whether to renovate the 70-year-old facility—or build a new one at a new site.

On Monday, Oak Ridge City Attorney Ken Krushenski said the contractual agreement between the city and ORNL and Y-12 started with the city’s takeover of the water plant in 2000. If the city and DOE can’t agree on rates, DOE could reclaim the plant, Krushenski said.

“Great!” Hensley responded.

Officials have previously said that turning the water plant back over to DOE would make the city the rate payer, and it would mean DOE would set water rates.

oak-ridge-city-council-trina-baughn-sept-14-2015-2

Trina Baughn (File photo by John Huotari/Oak Ridge Today)

Earlier this year, Oak Ridge officials said a residential water system like the city’s is different than a large consumer system like DOE’s system at ORNL and Y-12. There is a higher cost per unit in a residential system than in a large consumer system, Watson said. The large consumer system has large pipes moving water, while the residential system has small pipes with electricity-consuming pumps that move water up and down the hills of the city, he said.

A study presented to City Council in 2013 anticipated water and sewer rate increases on January 1 each year through fiscal year 2019, starting in January 2014. That was based on capital and debt service requirements, operating expenses, and inflation, among other funding considerations, McGinnis said.

Rate increases planned for January 2016 were delayed to January 2017, so the expected rate increases from 2016 to 2019 would be extended one year to 2017 through 2020.

There will be a rate review conducted in the summer of 2017.

McGinnis said Oak Ridge water rates are on the high side among surrounding municipal utility districts, although they are lower than some nearby rural utility districts. Oak Ridge’s system is residential-based and doesn’t have a lot of industry that is using water, McGinnis said.

More information will be added as it becomes available.

oak-ridge-city-council-hensley-callison-sept-14-2015

Oak Ridge City Council members Charlie Hensley, left, and Kelly Callison are pictured above during a Sept. 14, 2015, meeting. (File photo by John Huotari/Oak Ridge Today)

 

Do you appreciate this story or our work in general? If so, please consider a monthly subscription to Oak Ridge Today. See our Subscribe page here. Thank you for reading Oak Ridge Today.

Copyright 2016 Oak Ridge Today. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Filed Under: Front Page News, Government, Government, Oak Ridge, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Slider, U.S. Department of Energy, Y-12 National Security Complex Tagged With: Charlie Hensley, Chuck Hope, DOE, East Tennessee Technology Park, Ellen Smith, Janice McGinnis, Mark Watson, Oak Ridge, Oak Ridge City Council, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge Office, Oak Ridge Water Treatment Plant, ORNL, Pine Ridge, rate increases, Rick Chinn, Trina Baughn, U.S. Department of Energy, Warren Gooch, water, water and wastewater rate increases, water consumption, water contract, water rate, water system, Y-12, Y-12 National Security Complex

Advertisements

Join the club!

If you appreciate our work, please consider subscribing. Besides helping us, your subscription will give you access to our premium content.

Most of our stories are free, brought to you by Oak Ridge Today with help from our members—advertisers, subscribers, and sponsors.

But some are premium content, available only to members. Those are in-depth, investigative, or exclusive stories that are available only on Oak Ridge Today. They generally require at least four hours to report, write, and publish.

You can subscribe for as little as $5 per month.

You can read more about your options here.

We currently offer five primary subscription options to readers, and they include benefits.

Basic

  • Basic monthly subscription ($5 per month)—access premium content
  • Basic annual subscription ($60 per year)—access premium content

Pro

  • Pro monthly subscription ($10 per month)—access premium content, get breaking news emails first, and submit one press release or public service announcement per month
  • Pro annual subscription ($100 per year)—save $20 per year, access premium content, get breaking news emails first, and submit one press release or public service announcement per month

Temporary

  • Temporary access ($3 per week for two weeks)

We also have advanced subscription options. You can see them here.

We also accept donations. You can donate here.

If you prefer to send a check for a subscription or donation, you may do so by mailing one to:

Oak Ridge Today
P.O. Box 6064
Oak Ridge, TN 37831

Thank you for your consideration and for reading Oak Ridge Today. We appreciate your support.

Commenting Guidelines

We welcome comments, but we ask you to follow a few guidelines:

1) Please use your real name, including last name. Please also use a valid e-mail address.
2) Be civil. Don't insult others, attack their character, or get personal.
3) Stick to the issues.
4) No profanity.
5) Keep your comments to a reasonable length and to a reasonable number per article.

We reserve the right to remove any comments that violate these guidelines. Comments held for review, usually from those posting for the first time, may not post if they violate these guidelines. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Thank you also for reading Oak Ridge Today and for participating in the discussion.

More information is available here.

More Government News

Roane State helps with experiment to provide high-speed Internet access to rural communities

Roane State Community College played a crucial role in an experiment to get high-speed Internet to rural communities currently lacking what’s become an essential component of modern life. (Photo by Yvette … [Read More...]

Parking at Melton Lake Park to be closed for regatta March 13 & 14

Rowing at Melton Hill Lake (Photo courtesy City of Oak Ridge) The parking lots at Melton Lake Park will be closed to the public during a regatta next week. The regatta, the 2021 Oak Ridge Louisville Cardinal … [Read More...]

City of Oak Ridge Seal

Oak Ridge releases water quality report

The annual water quality report is now available for viewing on the City of Oak Ridge website, and the report says Oak Ridge water was in compliance with state and federal drinking water requirements, a press release … [Read More...]

Gov. Lee lifts nursing home restrictions, extends state of emergency

Bill Lee Tennessee Governor Bill Lee on Friday said he has extended a limited state of emergency through April 28 and lifted state visitation restrictions on nursing homes and long-term care facilities. The … [Read More...]

TVA conducting maintenance at Bull Run

The Tennessee Valley Authority's Bull Run Fossil Plant is pictured above in Claxton on Monday, Aug. 27, 2018. (File photo by John Huotari/Oak Ridge Today) The Tennessee Valley Authority is conducting routine … [Read More...]

More Government

More U.S. Department of Energy News

Granholm, a former governor, now energy secretary

Jennifer Granholm Note: This story was updated at 7:30 p.m. Jennifer Granholm, a former Michigan governor, was sworn in as energy secretary on Thursday. Granholm was the first female governor of Michigan, and … [Read More...]

Hear from ORNL scientists who worked on Perseverance mission

https://www.youtube.com/embed/mV1sYjE-zMU Video published on YouTube by Oak Ridge National Laboratory Three scientists at Oak Ridge National Laboratory will discuss their work this afternoon on technologies for the … [Read More...]

Bienvenue named first executive director of Oak Ridge Institute

Joan Bienvenue Joan Bienvenue has been selected as the first executive director of the Oak Ridge Institute at the University of Tennessee. "The institute was established last year to align the expertise and … [Read More...]

ORISE report shows overall number of nuclear engineering degrees increases to highest level since 2016

Part of the ORAU campus in central Oak Ridge is pictured above on May 29, 2017. (File photo by John Huotari/Oak Ridge Today) The number of nuclear engineering degrees awarded in 2019 were at the highest level since … [Read More...]

ORAU receives National Science Foundation grant to study greenhouse gases in Arctic

Praveena Krishnan The National Science Foundation Office of Polar Programs has awarded ORAU a collaborative research grant to study greenhouse gas emissions in the Arctic. The award is valued at $581,829. The grant … [Read More...]

More DOE

Recent Posts

  • Victim of Claxton shooting reported to be in critical but stable condition
  • Oak Ridge man dies in motorcycle crash on Oak Ridge Turnpike
  • Roane State helps with experiment to provide high-speed Internet access to rural communities
  • Parking at Melton Lake Park to be closed for regatta March 13 & 14
  • Regatta season starts next week
  • ORISE receives DOE silver award for GreenBuy program
  • Blasius to discuss Downtown Oak Ridge on Tuesday
  • Oak Ridge releases water quality report
  • Granholm, a former governor, now energy secretary
  • Gov. Lee lifts nursing home restrictions, extends state of emergency

Search Oak Ridge Today

About Us

About Oak Ridge Today
What We Cover

How To

Advertise
Subscribe

Contact Us

Contact Oak Ridge Today

Copyright © 2021 Oak Ridge Today