First legal challenge filed over ‘In God We Trust’ signs

Steve McDonald at In God We Trust Ceremony

During a Tuesday ceremony, Steve McDonald, left, pastor at Calvary Baptist Church in Oak Ridge, says the “In God We Trust” signs at the Anderson County Courthouse in Clinton honor the nation’s heritage and remind residents that “it is in God that we trust.” Also pictured are Kathy Moore, Tom Byrge, Anthony Allen, and Gil Bates.

Information from WYSH Radio

The first legal challenge to the signs bearing the inscription “In God We Trust” over the entrances to the Anderson County Courthouse came on Wednesday but not from any organization. Instead, it came from a man charged with attempted first-degree murder. Kenneth Darrin Fisher, 22, of Clinton is accused of the attempted first-degree murder of his wife and illegal possession of an assault rifle, and his case is due to go trial next spring.

Through attorney David Stuart, Fisher filed a motion in Anderson County Criminal Court on Wednesday seeking to dismiss all charges against him, asserting that the signs violate his freedom of worship rights under the U.S. and Tennessee constitutions. The motion states that Fisher is a blood member of the Cherokee Nation and a follower of “a Red Road” faith.

Calling the signs, one of which was installed Monday night and unveiled Tuesday morning, a “religious display” prohibited by both constitutions, Fisher asserts that they “reflect an endorsement by the government of a particularized and fundamentalist view of Christianity.” The motion also states that during Tuesday’s dedication and unveiling ceremony, the speakers, all of whom were of the Baptist faith, conveyed a fundamentalist Christian message that Fisher claims “[effectively] converted the [Courthouse] into a place of worship and recruitment and rendered it a temple of fundamentalist Christianity,” including comments from at least one speaker indicating that the inscriptions were being installed in part as a message to accused persons required to appear in court.

The motion also states that the message that was conveyed was that anyone who does not agree with the speakers on “matters of religion is going to hell.” Fisher, a military veteran who served in Afghanistan, says that he is offended by the “Constitutional affront” presented by the signs and objects to “being reminded that they have judged him as being destined to go to hell every time he passes through one of the entryways to the courthouse.”

The lawsuit seeks dismissal of the charges, as Stuart writes “there is no other effective remedy for the violation of constitutional rights…For example if [the court were to order] the permanent removal of the signs, it will become more difficult or impossible to impanel a fair and impartial jury for his trial.” Stuart writes that temporarily removing the signs or covering them would have a similar detrimental impact, and that Fisher is “entitled to have his trial in the Courthouse, untainted by unconstitutional religious displays.”

District Attorney General Dave Clark is reviewing the motion and preparing a response.

The other three signs are expected to be installed sometime today (Thursday). The project was paid for using more than $4,800 in donations from private citizens and approved by the County Commission earlier this year after lengthy and sometimes contentious debate.

Information in this story brought to you through an agreement between Oak Ridge Today and WYSH. See more local news headlines on the WYSH website at http://www.wyshradio.com/local_news.html.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Join the club!

If you support Oak Ridge Today, please consider becoming a voluntary subscriber. You don't have to subscribe to read our stories, but your contribution will help us grow and improve our coverage.

We currently offer three subscription levels: $5, $10, or $25 per month. We accept payments through PayPal. You may also visit our subscription page for information on other options.

Thank you for your support.


Subscription options




Advertisement
Advertisement

Commenting Guidelines

We welcome comments, but we ask you to follow a few guidelines:

1) Please use your real name, including last name. Please also use a valid e-mail address. We do our best to confirm identities. If we are unable to confirm your identity or your comments don't appear to be posted using a real, full name, your comments may not post or may be removed.
2) Be civil. Don't insult others, attack their character, or get personal.
3) Stick to the issues.
4) No profanity.
5) Keep your comments to a reasonable length and to a reasonable number per article.

We reserve the right to remove any comments that violate these guidelines. Comments from readers posting for the first time may be held for review, and they will not be posted if they violate the guidelines. We urge you to do your best to follow the guidelines if you would like to see your comment posted. Thank you for your patience and understanding.

More information is available here.

  • Mark Caldwell

    Gee, that didn’t take long.

  • Jason Allison

    By all means, this is a good reason to forgive this man of his felony acts.

    • Jason Allison

      Guess my sarcasm was lost

  • Jim Hudlow

    Forgive him his felony counts as a good xtian should….then stone him to death for not believing in the xtian god as is clearly stated in the KJV bible I just finished reading. We don’t need no stinkin’ civil laws!

    • Ck Kelsey

      Use the SPELL Check feature .Or remain Uneducated .LOL

More Government News

Oak Ridge Today

No garbage pickup on Labor Day

Waste Connections Inc. will not pick up garbage or recyclables on Monday, September 1 (Labor Day). Monday’s routes will be picked up on Tuesday, September 2, and the following subsequent days the rest of the … [Read More...]

More Government