• About
    • About Us
    • What We Cover
  • Advertise
    • Advertise
    • Our Advertisers
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Send News
  • Subscribe

Oak Ridge Today

  • Home
  • Sign in
  • News
    • Business
    • Community
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Police and Fire
    • U.S. Department of Energy
    • Weather
  • Sports
    • High School
    • Middle School
    • Recreation
    • Rowing
    • Youth
  • Entertainment
    • Arts
    • Dancing
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Television
    • Theater
  • Premium Content
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds


 







Opinion: A blueprint for growth, the choice is yours

Posted at 7:40 pm November 23, 2015
By Oak Ridge Today Staff 12 Comments

By Leonard Abbatiello

Nov. 19, 2015

In a previous article, I pointed out how Oak Ridge has changed. To summarize, we have changed drastically since the mid-1970s, becoming Tennessee average in median income, graduation rates, ethnic and age distributions. We are also heavily in debt, as we continue to spend beyond our means for all of our high quality services.

About 50 percent of our housing is over 70 years old and in various conditions located on lots that are often unsuitable for today’s desired off-street parking. Currently, over 12 percent of all homes are vacant, and those on the market are selling at 75 percent of their initial asking price. All aging residential housing is collectively dropping in both value and desirability. Our low-income population has increased to the point that they are the majority of our residents, and they cannot financially support our high-end services. Today, we are building only 10s of new homes annually, and a large percentage of the Manhattan Era housing remains vacant. Department of Energy radioactive and hazardous waste storage taints the community image as an attractive place to live.

We have evolved to this condition from a city that was given to us citizens debt free in the 1960s and rocketed to be the highest property taxed Tennessee city by 1973. Since then, it has endured a long list of both failed and evaporated DOE promised self-sufficiency projects. Today, DOE self-sufficiency efforts are no longer offered by DOE. Things even got worse following the 1985 fragmentation of all DOE single contractor federal operations, which then made effective local financial discussions impossible.

Advertisement

But there is still real hope! All we need to do is to demonstrate a little leadership, make our choice, and make a concerted effort to either reduce expenditures or increase revenues significantly. There are three known ways that can accomplish the goal without raising city property taxes. I will shortly list and discuss each of these choices, their status, and revenue potential. These are not new ideas, but they have been off limits for over 15 years and all have been politically untouchable because of fear of disturbing the status quo and personal gains for a few individuals. Simply stated, it was more acceptable to do nothing and just increase property taxes as Oak Ridge became less attractive and DOE workers began to live elsewhere.

There are three major ways to solve the Oak Ridge financial problem. Since 2004, all of these ideas have been politically removed from the table for discussion. I believe it is time to openly discuss them, make a choice, and work until we accomplish Councils’ choice.

These are:

  1. Negotiate a fair DOE PILT (payment in lieu of taxes) arrangement.
  2. Transfer responsibilities for police and/or the school system, or both to the county.
  3. Modify state law to eliminate double property taxation in all Tennessee cities.

Let’s discuss each:

DOE PILT status

Since about two-thirds of the Oak Ridge Reservation is still federal property, exempt from normal property taxation, DOE makes a payment in lieu of taxes, or PILT, annually to the City of Oak Ridge. This payment is based on the woodlands value and acreage as specified in the AECA of 1955. Additionally, Oak Ridge endures the stigma of being a radioactive and toxic waste dumping ground for DOE operations. Today this PILT yields about $1.7 million dollars, which is far below the approximately $20-24 million any normal city would receive from any such major industrial operation.

Advertisement

In 2000, the City Council began a serious effort to initiate negotiations for a new, fair-for-all-parties PILT agreement. These efforts yielded a Baker Donelson study that indicated that most Oak Ridge self-sufficiency efforts had failed miserably, and that the City of Oak Ridge should consider “every means available,” including legal suits, to bring DOE to the table and re-negotiate an improved COR/DOE PILT agreement with additional revenue.

In July 2004, the City of Oak Ridge had a letter signed by Senator Lamar Alexander and Senator Bill Frist sent to the Secretary of Energy, Mr. Spencer Abraham, requesting a city-DOE meeting on the failed self-sufficiency/PILT issue. The letter was not even answered by DOE and the city has done nothing to even find out why! A copy of this letter is attached. DOE needs to be paying its fair share of the cost of the City of Oak Ridge operations, or to complete effective, revenue-producing self-sufficiency projects. The city lawyer has a box containing the background, the study, and recommendations. DOE cannot be expected, without pressure, to voluntarily increase the Oak Ridge PILT payments or to consider our waste storage concerns.

Transfer policing responsibilities and/or school system operation to the county

Many people consider this idea unthinkable! But it is precisely what Knoxville, Nashville, Chattanooga, and Memphis have done to reduce or eliminate operational costs. Farragut was created without accepting these heavy burdens. If Oak Ridge wants to compete, it should consider such actions itself as major cost reductions are possible.

Cities have no standing under the federal, state, county governmental structure. Cities are simply allowed to exist and tax residents as an overlay. They do not displace any county, legal, taxation, or management requirements. City residents and city businesses must pay for both taxes.

The Oak Ridge City Charter contains provisions for accomplishing the transfer of both responsibilities to the county.

Transferring to the county some or all these costly responsibilities is the proven way of making major city expenditure reductions in Tennessee’s large cities.

Advertisement

Eliminate city double property taxation

Tennessee law just allows cities to exist and double tax our property. The action of most large cities has been to establish county-sized city perimeters and become metropolitan governments, which then provide all service functions under a single property tax structure. There is no double taxation in these metropolitan areas. Smaller cities cannot utilize the metropolitan government option. These smaller cities must either transfer service responsibilities to the county, or endure double property taxation.

I believe that Oak Ridge could provide the leadership to unify all 293 Tennessee cities to change Tennessee law, thus eliminating all double taxation of cities. Clearly, it would be a difficult uphill battle as the legislative bodies of Tennessee are county-based; most counties would lose both revenue and control. These are two things county politicos don’t want to lose, and therefore it is very difficult to pass such a law in a county-controlled Tennessee legislature.

See the Alexander and Frist letter here: Frist Alexander Letter to DOE July 04.

The potential for Oak Ridge is enormous! But only If DOE begins to pay its fair share of operations and consider us as a partner! It might be possible to even greatly reduce or nearly eliminate property taxes.  Additionally, if major cost reductions were implemented, property taxes could be completely eliminated and Oak Ridges’ financial future assured! If we properly priced and marketed our existing land, coupled with better-than-competitive taxation costs, we could attract new major industrial businesses and our housing growth would blossom!

My wish is that Council will make the hard decisions to both engage DOE and reduce expenditures.  The realistic way to accomplish this is to: 1) force DOE to reopen PILT and waste management decisions under the provisions of the AECA 1955 Act, employing every means available; and 2) significantly reduce both services and expenditures by transferring costly operations which are rightfully a county responsibility. You can either pursue your decision unilaterality, or with other governments, but you must make a decision if anything is to change!

You, our seven City Council members, are the only individuals who can direct any effort to improve the financial future of Oak Ridge and our relationship with DOE. You have the opportunity to define a bright competitive future, or do nothing. The four of you can really make a difference! What is your choice?

I will follow this article with a second one that describes how we may be able to accomplish our goal by teaming with the two other Energy Cities, utilizing our joint influence on both DOE and Congress, to create a win-win-win outcome for all!

Leonard Abbatiello is a former Oak Ridge City Council member.

***

Note: The submitted letters and columns published in the Opinion section do not necessarily reflect the views of Oak Ridge Today or its staff.

Copyright 2015 Oak Ridge Today. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Filed Under: Opinion Tagged With: City Council, DOE, DOE PILT, double property taxation, growth, housing, Leonard Abbatiello, Oak Ridge City Charter, Oak Ridge Reservation, payment in lieu of taxes, PILT, school system, toxic waste, U.S. Department of Energy, waste storage

Advertisements

 

Join the club!

If you appreciate our work, please consider subscribing. Besides helping us, your subscription will give you access to our premium content.

Most of our stories are free, brought to you by Oak Ridge Today with help from our members—advertisers, subscribers, and sponsors.

But some are premium content, available only to members. Those are in-depth, investigative, or exclusive stories that are available only on Oak Ridge Today. They generally require at least four hours to report, write, and publish.

You can subscribe for as little as $5 per month.

You can read more about your options here.

We currently offer five primary subscription options to readers, and they include benefits.

Basic

  • Basic monthly subscription ($5 per month)—access premium content
  • Basic annual subscription ($60 per year)—access premium content

Pro

  • Pro monthly subscription ($10 per month)—access premium content, get breaking news emails first, and submit one press release or public service announcement per month
  • Pro annual subscription ($100 per year)—save $20 per year, access premium content, get breaking news emails first, and submit one press release or public service announcement per month

Temporary

  • Temporary access ($3 per week for two weeks)

We also have advanced subscription options. You can see them here.

We also accept donations. You can donate here.

If you prefer to send a check for a subscription or donation, you may do so by mailing one to:

Oak Ridge Today
P.O. Box 6064
Oak Ridge, TN 37831

Thank you for your consideration and for reading Oak Ridge Today. We appreciate your support.

Commenting Guidelines

We welcome comments, but we ask you to follow a few guidelines:

1) Please use your real name, including last name. Please also use a valid e-mail address.
2) Be civil. Don't insult others, attack their character, or get personal.
3) Stick to the issues.
4) No profanity.
5) Keep your comments to a reasonable length and to a reasonable number per article.

We reserve the right to remove any comments that violate these guidelines. Comments held for review, usually from those posting for the first time, may not post if they violate these guidelines. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Thank you also for reading Oak Ridge Today and for participating in the discussion.

More information is available here.

More Opinion

Letter: Submarine Veterans base commander ‘very disappointed’ with festival this year

To the Editor: The Smoky Mountain Submarine Veterans, the Knoxville chapter of the United States Submarine Veterans, has had a booth and performed a Tolling of the Boats Ceremony at the Secret City Festival for the … [Read More...]

Five ways to foster resilience in young children

By Marjorie Alcorn: Home Visitor Healthy Families Tennessee/Prevent Child Abuse Tennessee East Region Resilience is defined as the ability to thrive, adapt and cope despite tough and stressful times. It’s a natural … [Read More...]

Letter: Oak Ridge Country Club responds to comments made at Council meeting

Editor's note: This is a letter sent to Oak Ridge City Council by the Oak Ridge Country Club in response to comments made during a City Council meeting in January, when Council considered whether to provide $120,000 for … [Read More...]

Opinion: How far can we move the needle?

By Ron Woody The buzz around the Roane County Courthouse and School Board has been what will our leaders do about the future of education in Roane County? The initial discussions were about consolidation of high … [Read More...]

Billy Paul Sams

Letter: Anderson County Bar Association wants to name law library after Billy Sams

Editor's note: The Anderson County Bar Association and legal community is proceeding with an effort to name the Anderson County Law Library after Billy Sams because "you never saw him without a book in his hands." Here … [Read More...]

More Opinion

Recent Posts

  • Controlled burns start this week on DOE land
  • Current status of city facilities due to COVID
  • Rep. Fleischmann tests positive for COVID
  • Oak Ridge man charged with second robbery
  • Mason, an IDB member, community volunteer, dies of COVID complications
  • Tammy Dunn appointed Oak Ridge city attorney
  • Which Wich closes
  • Obituary: David Lane Mason
  • Snow possible early Friday
  • Drone class to take flight this spring at Roane State

Recent Comments

  • Matt Bailey on Dodson also wants to serve as mayor pro tem
  • Mark Caldwell on Dodson also wants to serve as mayor pro tem
  • Matt Bailey on Dodson also wants to serve as mayor pro tem
  • Mark Caldwell on Dodson also wants to serve as mayor pro tem
  • Matt Bailey on Dodson also wants to serve as mayor pro tem
  • Tracy Powers on Planning Commission to consider Main Street apartments, plan revisions
  • johnhuotari on Four incumbents re-elected to Oak Ridge City Council
  • Levi D. Smith on Four incumbents re-elected to Oak Ridge City Council
  • samuel hopwood on Housing: Apartments proposed on former AMSE site
  • Matt Bailey on Robin Smith named Oak Ridge police chief

Search Oak Ridge Today

About Us

About Oak Ridge Today
What We Cover

How To

Advertise
Subscribe

Contact Us

Contact Oak Ridge Today

Copyright © 2021 Oak Ridge Today