• About
    • About Us
    • What We Cover
  • Advertise
    • Advertise
    • Our Advertisers
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Send News

Oak Ridge Today

  • Home
  • Sign in
  • News
    • Business
    • Community
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Police and Fire
    • U.S. Department of Energy
    • Weather
  • Sports
    • High School
    • Middle School
    • Recreation
    • Rowing
    • Youth
  • Entertainment
    • Arts
    • Dancing
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Television
    • Theater
  • Premium Content
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds

Opinion: A tale of three cities

Posted at 9:14 am June 6, 2016
By Oak Ridge Today Staff 12 Comments

By Trina Baughn

As we delve into what could be the last city budget I work on as a council member, I reflect upon both the state of the city and my contributions thus far. I could boast that, during my tenure, no property taxes were raised, and we’ve reduced total debt levels. However, those claims would be misleading given that council has so steeply expanded their reach into your pocket by other means. In fact, council is considering doing that very thing, yet again, with this budget. More on that in a moment.

Property taxes and debt paint only a partial picture of a city’s financial health. While both are very important, consideration must be given to their utility and return on investment. For many years, I have published in-depth analyses of some of the major expenditures that have brought us to the point we are today, such as:

  • How you were sold a $40 million high school that will, in the end, cost you over $126 million.
  • The fact that the city, not the EPA, was at fault for your water and sewer rates doubling in only a few short years, thereby incurring $33 million worth of debt on top of  the $24 million we’d already spent to avoid the EPA mandate.
  • An accounting of the $10 million you’ve paid on a golf course you were assured would pay for itself but hasn’t and won’t for many more years to come, if ever.
  • Your annual $175,000 subsidy (compare to Farragut, which only spends $15,000) of a Chamber of Commerce that is largely made up of nonprofits, government organizations, and non-Oak Ridge businesses that regularly pressure council to increase your property taxes.
  • Frequent disclosures of excessive, non-essential spending such as a $275,000 parking lot, a $1 million fountain, a $300,000 bathroom and much, much more.
  • How crony capitalism has run amuck, forcing you to offset the extensive corporate welfare the city doles out on your behalf.
  • Demonstrating that you are likely overpaying for your trash services with Waste Connections, which is charging less in communities where they had to compete.
  • Reminding you of the broken promises of Partners for Progress, which cost you $15 million on the failed Rarity Ridge/Horizon Center development 16 years ago and warning of similar pitfalls in the $13 million mall TIF (tax increment financing).
  • And, because half of your property taxes fund our schools, I frequently challenged our superintendent and school board when they would demand more of your money on the grounds that, in spite of being the one of the most heavily funded systems in the state, much of your money is not making it into the classroom where it belongs.

Some will view the above examples through a different lens if they rely upon what they see around town. We have certainly seen an uptick in eateries, and we can all appreciate the aesthetic value of some of the new developments. Those new developments have, however, displaced some pre-existing businesses, leaving us with an abundance of vacant properties.

To their credit, both council and the schools have actually made some cuts. Unfortunately, none of those recaptured funds were returned to you. And even though promises were made to reduce the property tax when revenues materialized, that has yet to happen. This budget, for example, projects a $3.2 million increase in revenues since 2012. Rather than return that to you in the form of a 37-cent tax reduction, the city manager has proposed we turn over some of that money to the schools, who are sitting on nearly $6 million that they can, per their own audit, “spend at their own discretion” (see page 17 here).

Three years ago, I wrote a column I that explored our city’s economic decline and proposed course-correcting steps. I presented an analysis of our nearest and strongest competitor with a challenge that we learn from them.

In brief, with no debt, zero municipal property taxes, or significant expense on economic development ruses, Farragut’s fiscally conservative approach produced phenomenal, demonstrable return on investment. They’d successfully enticed U.S. Department of Energy employees to reside in their town, resulting in an average annual household income twice that of ours and a population growth rate triple ours.

Since council is considering increasing school funding, issuing $9 million in new debt, and upping your water/sewer bill another 6 percent, it is practical to revisit our competitive position.

Though council did not vote in a tax increase, last year’s assessment bumped our combined property tax rate from $4.74 to $5.11, ranking Oak Ridge/Anderson County as the second-highest taxed municipality in East Tennessee. Taking over the top spot is nearby Newport of Cocke County, which voted in a major rate increase, bringing them up to $5.48.

We’ve obviously chosen not to follow Farragut’s lead, so let’s examine the city with whom we are tracking. Like Oak Ridge, Newport is a picturesque community with its own unique legacy (google “Cocke County Confidential.”) While we’ve seen very modest population gains since 2000 (7 percent), they’ve lost 5 percent of their residents. Farragut has grown 22 percent. Perhaps the most telling indicator of progress (or lack thereof) is average household income. Ours ($50,000) is half that of Farragut ($99,000) while Newport’s is less than half ours at $21,000.

On the education front, Newport has a slightly higher percentage of economically disadvantaged students (58 percent to our 55 percent), and their students are testing at about the same level as ours in the core subjects of math and reading, grades 3-8. See the chart below for most recent statistics as well as those of Farragut.

Those figures don’t bode well, and some will certainly argue that progress, decline and stagnation are subjective. However, if you walk away with nothing else, consider this: Both our debt and our low-income population have nearly tripled over the last 20 years.

Those who are able to afford Oak Ridge’s higher cost of living, our middle and upper class, have left and will continue to do so, many waiting until right after their children graduate. If we continue our current trajectory, we will undoubtedly see them disappear altogether.

But Oak Ridge doesn’t have to become the next Newport. We have a significant resource they lack, and it is literally right in our back yard. With a billion dollars in annual payroll at stake, we can, and should, aggressively seek to steal back DOE residents.

At the same time, we have to consider austerity measures before they are no longer an option. Many municipalities have filed bankruptcy, something previously thought to be highly improbable, in spite of safe bond ratings. Many of the solutions I’ve offered in the past are still doable, such as:

  • Converting city-owned assets into taxable properties like our vacant buildings in Commerce Park, the golf course, or the corner lot the Chamber of Commerce occupies.
  • Reducing some of the $1 million-plus you pay to fund local and non-local travel expenses.
  • Reducing non-critical positions through attrition. There are over 1,100 city and school employees. While most positions are necessary, not everyone is essential. We surely could afford not to backfill some of the 5-10 percent who retire or go elsewhere every year.
  • Shave 5 cents off the property tax rate by enacting a temporary 10 percent pay cut on the 40-plus city director/school administrator salaries who are averaging over $90,000 and reinstate once the promises of the UPF, Mall, and CVMR materialize.

Throughout the years, many of you have shared with me your frustrations about our city and asked what can be done. Though the answer is simple, it does require a prolonged commitment to hold your elected officials accountable. Attendance at our meetings is primarily limited to the “good ole boys” who’ve been running the show for decades. The working class people of this community need to take back their rightful seats and have their say at the podium and in the papers.

It is too easy to collectively hang together, so single us out on our votes, not our rhetoric. You’ve got at least two council members who aspire to take over Randy McNally’s senate seat. They know they can’t both win, and they know they have to be viewed as fiscally conservative if they stand a chance at winning. Pressure them. Hold them accountable publicly and often.

Council will hold two public hearings and votes on the FY17 city budget on June 6 and June 13 at 7 p.m. at the municipal building. Whether you agree with my position or not, I encourage you attend and exercise your right to be heard.

Trina Baughn is an Oak Ridge City Council member.

Oak Ridge (Anderson) Newport (Cocke) Farragut (Knox)
2015 Combined Tax Rate $5.11 $5.48 $2.32
2014 Combined Tax Rate $4.74 $4.15 $2.32
Average Household Income $50,486 $21,070 $98,834
Average Home Value $140,337 $90,106 $325,964
Population Change Since 2000 7% -5% 22%
School Per Pupil Spending $12,355 $9,216 $9,043
Economically Disadvantaged Students 55% 58% 16%
Grades 3-8 Testing Below Grade Level: Math 43% 45% 22%
Grades 3-8 Testing Below Grade Level: Reading 44% 43% 26%

Sources:

https://www.comptroller.tn.gov/pa/CountyInfo.asp

http://www.city-data.com/city/Newport-Tennessee.html

https://www.tn.gov/assets/entities/education/attachments/asr_1415.pdf

***

Note: The submitted letters and columns published in the Opinion section do not necessarily reflect the views of Oak Ridge Today or its staff.

Copyright 2016 Oak Ridge Today. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Filed Under: Opinion Tagged With: budget, debt, Farragut, Newport, Oak Ridge, Oak Ridge City Council, property taxes, school funding, Trina Baughn, U.S. Department of Energy

Comments

  1. Joseph Lee says

    June 6, 2016 at 12:31 pm

    It is sad that the soon to be former council member has squandered the opportunity provided her by the voters of our city. The “solutions” she offered went nowhere due to her own inability and unwillingness to work with others in a constructive manner. Combine that with the seemingly endless assaults against individuals and institutions in Oak Ridge and the result is a self inflicted failure as a council member. Ms. Baughn’s political career will soon be six feet under. Thank you.

    Reply
    • Sam Hopwood says

      June 6, 2016 at 7:47 pm

      Your “ghostwriter” performs in a much softer format than you do Joe. Did she not do a bit of “ghost writing” for a former OR mayor at one time? Thank you. 🙂

      Reply
  2. Tracy Powers says

    June 6, 2016 at 5:19 pm

    Anyone that took the time to read Trina’s long-winded rubbish has not learned their lesson regarding Ms. Baughn.

    Let me save you the trouble by condensing it: Lie, bragging, lie, foolish talk, lie, exaggeration, lie, nonsense, trash, lie.

    Her advice to hold our elected officials accountable is ironic, coming from her. What a waste of a good city council seat she has proven herself to be. A loose cannon with no regard for the truth.

    Our city council meetings aren’t “limited” to the good old boys, as Trina claims. They are wide open for anyone to attend.

    Good riddance, Trina, don’t let the door hit you on the way out.

    Reply
    • Mike Mahathy says

      June 7, 2016 at 5:44 pm

      The councilwoman refuses to admit the truth about fund balance.

      https://mikemahathyoakridgeboe.com/2016/05/31/fund-balance/

      Perhaps we might be more happy in Newport.

      I am thankful that our city continues to move forward under the leadership and support from most Oak Ridgers.

      Reply
      • Trina Baughn says

        June 8, 2016 at 9:39 am

        Mr. Mahanky,

        Please see the following: https://trinabaughn.com/2016/06/08/leftover-school-fund-money-the-data-doesnt-lie/ .

        Especially note this line: The school finance director claims that they have or will use $2M of the $6M referenced in the 2015 audit. If history repeats itself, they’ll still have much of that $2M leftover come this time next year (note that even though they tapped $2.25M in 2014, 2015’s end balance was actually higher.)

        Reply
        • Mike Mahathy says

          June 8, 2016 at 11:15 am

          If history repeats itself they will need the funds to pay payroll and other operating expenses at various times of the year. Thank you for acknowledging our schools need a fund balance.

          Reply
          • Matt Bailey says

            June 8, 2016 at 11:33 am

            Mike, I met the “little boy who cried wolf”. He said: “if you think I’m bad, have you met councilwoman Baughn”? When I told him I knew her, his response was: “see, I’m not so bad”!! Enough said.

        • Mike Mahathy says

          June 8, 2016 at 6:04 pm

          Ms Baughn,

          First I am not a “good old boy” and there are seats at City Council for anyone who wishes to attend. I have heard multiple people speak representing all sides of issues. As far as the BOE not allowing the public to talk, you know as well as anyone public comments are generally not scheduled at special meetings of city council or BOE though I am not defending BOE. They need no defense.

          Reply
        • Tracy Powers says

          June 12, 2016 at 3:42 pm

          Trina, you have yet to realize that what little credibility you held in the past, you have since proven time and time again you weren’t worthy of even that little bit.

          BTW, have you ever apologized to Chief Akagi, his family and the citizens of Oak Ridge for the outright lies you told regarding his character and his personal life? Or are you still refusing to admit you were wrong? You were told time and time again by many people that you were wrong and WHY you were wrong.

          You refused to listen to anyone. Your personal vendetta against him came to light and proved your lack of character as we knew it would. You have no one to blame but yourself, unfortunately, I doubt you do.

          Reply
  3. Mike Mahathy says

    June 8, 2016 at 11:28 am

    John Huotari, Would you consider printing the memo from Karen G to Mark Watson that addresses fund balance over the course of a year? That document should disspell the notion that OR Schools are sitting on $6 million and show why fund balance is needful.

    Reply
  4. Joseph Lee says

    June 8, 2016 at 1:49 pm

    Hang in there folks. 153 days to go and it’s over for Ms. Baughn.
    We are 89.589% done with her as an elected official in Oak Ridge.

    Reply
  5. Emilee Smith says

    June 12, 2016 at 10:35 pm

    Ms Baughn speaks a lot about money that has been wasted or spent foolishly in this article. Nowhere does she ever mention all of the time and resources wasted (which equals money and lots of it) that has been used to defend the city and some of its officials against her false claims. I cannot wait to get council members that can think for themselves and work constructively to do what helps Oak Ridge instead of hurting it the way that she has.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Opinion

Letter: Submarine Veterans base commander ‘very disappointed’ with festival this year

To the Editor: The Smoky Mountain Submarine Veterans, the Knoxville chapter of the United States Submarine Veterans, has had a booth and performed a Tolling of the Boats Ceremony at the Secret City Festival for the … [Read More...]

Five ways to foster resilience in young children

By Marjorie Alcorn: Home Visitor Healthy Families Tennessee/Prevent Child Abuse Tennessee East Region Resilience is defined as the ability to thrive, adapt and cope despite tough and stressful times. It’s a natural … [Read More...]

Letter: Oak Ridge Country Club responds to comments made at Council meeting

Editor's note: This is a letter sent to Oak Ridge City Council by the Oak Ridge Country Club in response to comments made during a City Council meeting in January, when Council considered whether to provide $120,000 … [Read More...]

Opinion: How far can we move the needle?

By Ron Woody The buzz around the Roane County Courthouse and School Board has been what will our leaders do about the future of education in Roane County? The initial discussions were about consolidation of high … [Read More...]

Billy Paul Sams

Letter: Anderson County Bar Association wants to name law library after Billy Sams

Editor's note: The Anderson County Bar Association and legal community is proceeding with an effort to name the Anderson County Law Library after Billy Sams because "you never saw him without a book in his hands." Here … [Read More...]

More Opinion

Recent Posts

  • Flatwater Tales Storytelling Festival Announces 2025 Storytellers
  • Laser-Engraved Bricks Will Line Walkway of New Chamber Headquarters
  • Democratic Women’s Club to Discuss Climate Change, Energy and Policy
  • Estate Jewelry Show at Karen’s Jewelers Features Celebrity Jewelry
  • Keri Cagle named new ORAU senior vice president and ORISE director
  • ORAU Annual Giving Campaign exceeds $100,000 goal+ORAU Annual Giving Campaign exceeds $100,000 goal More than $1 million raised in past 10 years benefits United Way and Community Shares Oak Ridge, Tenn. —ORAU exceeded its goal of raising $100,000 in donations as part of its internal annual giving campaign that benefits the United Way and Community Shares nonprofit organizations. ORAU has raised more than $1 million over the past 10 years through this campaign. A total of $126,839 was pledged during the 2024 ORAU Annual Giving Campaign. Employees donate via payroll deduction and could earmark their donation for United Way, Community Shares or both. “ORAU has remained a strong pillar in the community for more than 75 years, and we encourage our employees to consider participating in our annual giving campaign each year to help our less fortunate neighbors in need,” said ORAU President and CEO Andy Page. “Each one of our employees has the power to positively impact the lives of those who need help in the communities where we do business across the country and demonstrate the ORAU way – taking care of each other.” ORAU, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit corporation, provides science, health and workforce solutions that address national priorities and serve the public interest. Through our specialized teams of experts and access to a consortium of more than 150 major Ph.D.-granting institutions, ORAU works with federal, state, local and commercial customers to provide innovative scientific and technical solutions and help advance their missions. ORAU manages the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education (ORISE) for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Learn more about ORAU at www.orau.org. Learn more about ORAU at www.orau.org. Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/OakRidgeAssociatedUniversities Follow us on X (formerly Twitter): https://twitter.com/orau Follow us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/orau ###
  • Children’s Museum Gala Celebrates the Rainforest
  • Jim Sears joins ORAU as senior vice president
  • Oak Ridge Housing Authority Receives Funding Assistance of up to $51.8 Million For Renovating Public Housing and Building New Workforce Housing
  • Two fires reported early Friday

Search Oak Ridge Today

Copyright © 2025 Oak Ridge Today