• About
    • About Us
    • What We Cover
  • Advertise
    • Advertise
    • Our Advertisers
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Send News
  • Subscribe

Oak Ridge Today

  • Home
  • Sign in
  • News
    • Business
    • Community
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Police and Fire
    • U.S. Department of Energy
    • Weather
  • Sports
    • High School
    • Middle School
    • Recreation
    • Rowing
    • Youth
  • Entertainment
    • Arts
    • Dancing
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Television
    • Theater
  • Premium Content
  • Obituaries
  • Classifieds

 

Appeals court rules in favor of Covenant Health, other defendants in excessive radiation lawsuit

Posted at 6:29 pm June 25, 2015
By John Huotari Leave a Comment

Methodist Medical Center Main Entrance

A three-judge appeals court panel has ruled in favor of Covenant Health and two other defendants in five lawsuits that alleged that the absence of shielding in part of the emergency department at Methodist Medical Center exposed five X-ray and radiologic technologists, including two who were pregnant, to excessive radiation.

The unanimous opinions by the three Tennessee Court of Appeals judges—D. Michael Swiney, John W. McClarty, and Thomas R. Frierson II—were filed June 9 in Knoxville. They affirmed an order by Anderson County Circuit Court Judge Donald R. Elledge granting a summary judgement in favor of the defendants: Covenant Health, Rentenbach Engineering Company, and TEG Architects LLC.

The lawsuits were filed in January 2014 by Connie Raby, Keith Gillis, Michael Phillips, Mary Ridenour on behalf of her and her child, and Micah Noelle Lewellen on behalf of her and her child.

The lawsuits alleged that the technologists were exposed to excess radiation for several years at Methodist Medical Center because some walls in and around a radiology imaging center in the new emergency department, which opened in February 2006 as part of a hospital remodel, were built without the required lead shielding, elevating the workers’ risk of health problems, including cancer.

Advertisement

But the defendants filed motions for summary judgement, and Elledge granted them. The defendants argued that a construction statute known as the statute of repose had expired.

But the plaintiffs appealed, arguing that the statute of repose did not run because the absence of the required shielding in the radiology facilities meant the project was not substantially completed on the date determined by the Anderson County Circuit Court.

The Tennessee Court of Appeals disagreed.

“We hold…that the radiology facilities, while perhaps defective, were used for their intended purpose and were substantially complete as found by the trial court,” the three-judge panel said in its unanimous decision. “The construction statute of repose expired and serves to defeat plaintiffs’ claims. We affirm the trial court.”

In the Circuit Court order, Elledge said the lawsuits were construction lawsuits involving errors and omissions, where one panel of lead-lined Sheetrock was left out of the X-ray room.

Elledge said there was a notice of substantial completion filed in March 2006, and the room was used between March 2006 and December 2013 as an X-ray and CT room.

Tennessee’s construction statute of repose would require actions seeking to recover damages to be brought within four years after substantial completion of the improvement, Elledge said.

“I have nothing that contradicts the date of completion, of substantial completion, as defined by statute and case law being on or about March 23, 2006,” Elledge said. “I find nothing, nothing, in the record that contradicts the fact that none of the defendants in this case knew or attempted to fraudulently conceal any cause of injury that is allegedly suffered by the plaintiffs in each of these five cases.”

Advertisement

But the plaintiffs argued that the absence of the shielding in the wall meant that the construction project was not substantially completed until that defect was corrected.

“Therefore, according to plaintiffs, the statute of repose did not expire because it never started running until the defect was corrected,” the three-judge appellate court panel said in its discussion of the case.

But, the Appeals Court said, “the undisputed evidence in the record on appeal is that the emergency department, including the CT room at issue, was used from March 2006. The fact that the improvement allegedly was defective does not prevent that improvement from being substantially complete.”

The Appeals Court said it is clear that the Tennessee General Assembly intended to set an outer limit to liability arising from defective work on improvements to real property through the construction statute of repose.

The plaintiffs filed their lawsuits in January 2014.

“The four-year statute of repose had long expired, and this serves to defeat plaintiffs’ claims,” the judges said.

The three judges said the costs on appeal are assessed against the appellants, which were the plaintiffs in the lawsuits.

When the suits were filed, Lewellen, of Knoxville, was an X-ray technologist allegedly exposed to radiation during her pregnancy; Gillis, of Knoxville, was a radiologic technologist (computed tomography technologist); Phillips, of Clinton, was a radiologic technologist (computed tomography technologist); Raby, of Clinton, was a X-ray technologist; and Ridenour, of Andersonville, was a radiologic technologist (computed tomography technologist) who was allegedly exposed to radiation during her pregnancy.

Advertisement

MMC, a Covenant Health member, said it placed the highest priority on employee and public safety.

“We maintain an active and ongoing radiation quality and compliance program with specific procedures to monitor safety,” the hospital said in a statement after the suits were filed. “Based on the results of this program, it has been verified that we have met all safety standards for radiation exposure.”

You can access the opinions here.

More information will be added as it becomes available.

Copyright 2015 Oak Ridge Today. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Filed Under: Anderson County, Business, Front Page News, Government, Health, Health, Oak Ridge, Slider, State, Top Stories Tagged With: Anderson County Circuit Court, cancer, Connie Raby, Covenant Health, D. Michael Swiney, emergency department, excessive radiation, John W. McClarty, Keith Gillis, lead shielding, Mary Ridenour, Methodist Medical Center, Micah Noelle Lewellen, Michael Phillips, MMC, radiologic technologist, radiology imaging center, Rentenbach Engineering Company, shielding, statute of repose, substantial completion, summary judgement, TEG Architects LLC, Tennessee Court of Appeals, Thomas R. Frierson II, X-ray technologist

Advertisements

 


Join the club!

If you appreciate our work, please consider subscribing. Besides helping us, your subscription will give you access to our premium content.

Some of our stories are free, brought to you by Oak Ridge Today with help from our members—advertisers, subscribers, and sponsors.

But some are premium content, available only to members. Those are in-depth, investigative, or exclusive stories that are available only on Oak Ridge Today. They generally require significant time to report, write, and publish.

You can subscribe for as little as $5 per month.

You can read more about your options here.

We currently offer five primary subscription options to readers, and they include benefits.

Basic

  • Basic monthly subscription ($5 per month)—access premium content
  • Basic annual subscription ($60 per year)—access premium content

Pro

  • Pro monthly subscription ($10 per month)—access premium content, get breaking news emails first, and submit one press release or public service announcement per month
  • Pro annual subscription ($100 per year)—save $20 per year, access premium content, get breaking news emails first, and submit one press release or public service announcement per month

Temporary

  • Temporary access ($3 per week for two weeks)

We also have advanced subscription options. You can see them here.

We also accept donations. You can donate here.

If you prefer to send a check for a subscription or donation, you may do so by mailing one to:

Oak Ridge Today
P.O. Box 6064
Oak Ridge, TN 37831

Thank you for your consideration and for reading Oak Ridge Today. We appreciate your support.

Commenting Guidelines

We welcome comments, but we ask you to follow a few guidelines:

1) Please use your real name, including last name. Please also use a valid e-mail address.
2) Be civil. Don't insult others, attack their character, or get personal.
3) Stick to the issues.
4) No profanity.
5) Keep your comments to a reasonable length and to a reasonable number per article.

We reserve the right to remove any comments that violate these guidelines. Comments held for review, usually from those posting for the first time, may not post if they violate these guidelines. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Thank you also for reading Oak Ridge Today and for participating in the discussion.

More information is available here.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Business News

Speakers mostly support TRISO-X fuel facility at meeting

A small group of residents who spoke at a public meeting on Wednesday were mostly supportive of a proposed nuclear fuel facility in west Oak Ridge. None of the seven local speakers opposed the project, but they had some … [Read More...]

Residents discuss Dollar General in Marlow

A handful of Anderson County residents have expressed mixed opinions in government meetings about a reported proposal to build a Dollar General store next to Oliver Springs Highway in Marlow, but the Anderson County … [Read More...]

NRC accepting comments on environmental review for nuclear fuel facility

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission will have a public meeting in Oak Ridge next week to accept public comments about the environmental review for a proposed nuclear fuel facility at Horizon Center. It would be the … [Read More...]

Planning Commission approves Weigel’s site plan

The Oak Ridge Municipal Planning Commission approved a site plan Thursday evening for a new Weigel's at South Illinois Avenue and Union Valley Road. The plan for the 6,600-square foot store on an undeveloped 3.6-acre … [Read More...]

Railroad could jeopardize airport

Railroad tracks at Heritage Center, the former K-25 site, have emerged as a potential "deal-killer" for the proposed Oak Ridge Airport. On Tuesday, Oak Ridge city leaders said a new company in west Oak Ridge might … [Read More...]

More Business

More Government News

Residents discuss Dollar General in Marlow

A handful of Anderson County residents have expressed mixed opinions in government meetings about a reported proposal to build a Dollar General store next to Oliver Springs Highway in Marlow, but the Anderson County … [Read More...]

Read city manager’s retirement letter

This is a copy of the January 17 retirement letter from Oak Ridge City Manager Mark Watson to the seven Oak Ridge City Council members. Since August of 2010, I have been proud to serve the City of Oak Ridge as its … [Read More...]

Oak Ridge Public Library

Library restrooms will be renovated

The restrooms at the Oak Ridge Public Library will be renovated starting February 1. The renovations are expected to be completed by June 1. The renovations will result in increased accessibility under Americans … [Read More...]

Breakfast with Legislators resumes Monday

Breakfast with the Legislators begins this year on Monday. The monthly breakfasts are scheduled each year while the Tennessee General Assembly is in session. They are hosted by the League of Women Voters of Oak Ridge, … [Read More...]

Former AC Commissioner Hitchcock dies

Note: This story was updated at 11:30 a.m. Harry "Whitey" Hitchcock, who represented part of Oak Ridge in three terms on Anderson County Commission, died January 10. A former teacher, he was 76. Hitchcock served on … [Read More...]

More Government

Recent Posts

  • Basketball: Wildcats beat West in rematch
  • Basketball: Lady Wildcats undefeated in district
  • Obituaries: Jan. 23-27, 2023
  • Speakers mostly support TRISO-X fuel facility at meeting
  • UPF construction could cost more, take longer
  • Y-12 celebrates new fire station, emergency operations center
  • One person seriously injured in Wednesday crash
  • Oak Ridge EM prepared for cold weather to prevent failures
  • Covenant Health donating land for Roane State health science center
  • School board approves aviation career path

Search Oak Ridge Today

About Us

About Oak Ridge Today
What We Cover

How To

Advertise
Subscribe

Contact Us

Contact Oak Ridge Today

Copyright © 2023 Oak Ridge Today